Case 1 answers
The Bar Incident is the widest gate in the game — 775,184 players have cleared it — and it falls to one contradiction Marcus hands you in his opening answer.
The four angles that work
The leaving time he gave you
He commits to around 9:30 in his first answer and never stops defending it. Ask what time he actually left, then put the camera timestamp against it. The fifteen minutes between his story and the footage has no reasonable explanation, which is why this is the fastest route in the game.
Why the camera still has him there after ten
A sharper version of the same pressure, and one players report working: he cannot be walking home at half nine and still be on camera at ten. Make him pick one.
The hammer with his fingerprints, in a dumpster
Do not open with the hammer — he has a rehearsed answer about half his crew owning the same one. Once his timeline is already broken, the dumpster is the harder question: a common tool does not explain his prints on a discarded one.
The bartender he volunteered
He offers the bartender as his alibi. That is a name he chose, so ask what the bartender would say about the time — he now has to defend a witness he introduced.
Roblox AI Interrogation
Nio · 45,586 views
Case 1 start to finish, including the moment Marcus breaks. This is the run our Case 1 quotes are transcribed from.
A full run at this case, including the point where Marcus stops denying and starts bargaining.
What he says when he breaks
Marcus does not hold out the way later suspects do. He gets vague, then wounded, then starts complaining about being framed — and once he stops arguing about the hammer, the shift is quick.
“I didn't mean to. We got into an argument. I hit her with the hammer. … Yes, I did it. I'm sorry.”
What not to spend questions on
- The hammer, early. “It is a pretty common tool in the trade” is a complete answer and it costs him nothing.
- Asking whether he did it. He will say no, and the bar will not move.
- His tiredness. He blames a twelve-hour shift for misremembering the time. Accepting that framing hands him the excuse.